Child Nutrition. Childhood Nutrition. Is it scholarly or professional? Does it meet the majority of the these criteria? The author is typically a scholar, researcher or professional in the field. The writing style is usually scholarly, technical or formal. The author often uses terminology that requires some familiarity with the subject or profession. Edited by journalists who may or may not have specialized knowledge of the topics of articles. Full editorial information is usually not provided, often just the name of the Editor in Chief or a few main editors.
Articles are subjected to some form of peer review by outside experts in the topic covered by the article before being accepted for publication. Articles may be returned to the authors for revision before being accepted.
Research articles, especially in science and health science journals, may contain the following sections: abstract, literature review, methodology, results and conclusion. Always remember that just because a journal has the word "journal" in the title, does not mean that it's a scholarly journal.
On the other hand, many scholarly journal titles do not contain the word "journal". For example, the Wall Street Journal is a financial newspaper, not a scholarly journal, and American Literature is a peer reviewed scholarly journal. In addition, not every article in a peer reviewed publication undergoes review. There may be editorials, letters to the editor, and book reviews in scholarly journals that are not refereed.
It is important to evaluate each article to determine if it is acceptable for your needs. If you're not sure of the type of a particular article ask a librarian for assistance. For more help, ask a librarian. During the peer-review process, information is reviewed by several experts in the field, who vet the information for bias, reliability, and validity; suggest possible changes; and recommend to the publisher whether or not to publish the information.
The peer-review process is a sort of "checks and balances" system for scholarly information. For the aforementioned reasons, scholarly information sources are viewed as being more authoritative, while popular information sources are viewed as being less credible.
Additionally, scholarly information is published for the sole purpose of exploring theories, introducing new ideas, presenting research findings, and, overall, adding to the body of research in a particular discipline. This is why instructors often require students to use scholarly, peer-reviewed articles, rather than popular articles, for their research.
Professional or trade literature resembles scholarly literature in that it is typically written by people working in the field, but may be written by staff writers with expertise. They might include advertisements, although most or all are profession- or trade-specific.
Answer A scholarly journa l is also called an academic journal. Topics Periodicals Journals. FAQ Actions. Was this helpful? Yes 12 No Print Tweet Share on Facebook. Comments 0. Add a public comment to this FAQ Entry.
0コメント